Development challenges associated with rAAV-based gene therapies.

The number of gene therapies in development continues to increase, as they represent a novel method to treat, and potentially cure, many diseases. Gene therapies can be conducted with an in vivo or ex vivo approach, to cause gene augmentation, gene suppression, or genomic editing. Adeno-associated viruses are commonly used to deliver gene therapies, but their use is associated with several manufacturing, nonclinical and clinical challenges. As these challenges emerge, regulatory agency expectations continue to evolve. Following administration of rAAV-based gene therapies, nonclinical toxicities may occur, which includes immunogenicity, hepatotoxicity, neurotoxicity, and the potential risks for insertional mutagenesis and subsequent tumorgenicity. The mechanism for these findings and translation into the clinical setting are unclear at this time but have influenced the nonclinical studies that regulatory agencies are increasingly requesting to support clinical trials and marketing authorizations. These evolving regulatory expectations and toxicities, as well as future nonclinical considerations, are discussed herein.

Shared Learnings on the New EMA First-in-Human and Early Clinical Trial Guideline: Proceedings From a DIAlogue Session at DIA Europe 2018.

The EU is a member of the International Council for Harmonization of Technical Requirements for Pharmaceuticals for Human Use (ICH), and therefore adopts the ICH Guidelines, including the ICH M3 Guideline on Nonclinical Safety Studies. Following the 2016 incident in France with BIA 10-2474, and in light of the substantial evolvement of how early clinical development has been undertaken during the last 10 years, for example, conducting integrated (FIH) studies that include multiple parts (eg, single ascending doses, multiple ascending doses, food effect), EMA decided to update the existing 2007 FIH guideline. The key revisions to the 2007 guideline, now titled "Guideline on Strategies to Identify and Mitigate Risks for First-in-Human and Early Clinical Trials With Investigational Medicinal Products," include additional information. The revision reinforces the importance and impact of pharmacologic data, which supports the intended efficacy of the compound, risk assessment, and protocol design. The updates, effective February 2018, are intended to provide additional guidance and clarity for Sponsors developing FIH and early phase clinical research programs, and ultimately support subject safety. At the 2018 DIA Europe Annual Meeting in Basel, Switzerland, European regulators, industry representatives and academics convened a DIAlogue Session on April 17 to discuss how the revised 2017 guideline is being applied, and to establish recommendations for its application. Using two case studies as examples, the session participants discussed the nonclinical and clinical considerations for applying the newly revised recommendations, and interacted with a panel including regulators and industry representatives. The proceedings from this session reflect practical considerations for the implementation of the revised guideline.

Drug-induced Skin Lesions in Cynomolgus Macaques Treated with Metabotropic Glutamate Receptor 5 (mGluR5) Negative Allosteric Modulators.

Three orally administered metabotropic glutamate receptor 5 (mGluR5) negative allosteric modulators caused skin lesions consistent with delayed type-IV hypersensitivity in cynomolgus macaques in 2- and 12-week toxicity studies. Several monkeys developed macroscopic skin lesions in multiple locations after 8 to 9 days of dosing; the most prominent effects involved the genital region of males and generalized erythema occurred in both sexes. Microscopic lesions occurred in both clinically affected and unaffected areas and were characterized by lymphocytic interface inflammation, subepidermal bullae, and individual keratinocyte vacuolation/necrosis. In the 12-week study, clinical effects in 2 animals resolved with continued dosing, whereas in others the inflammatory process progressed with 1 female exhibiting systemic lymphocytic inflammation in multiple tissues. The inflammatory infiltrate consisted of CD3 and CD4 positive T lymphocytes with minimal CD68 positive macrophages and only rare CD8 positive T lymphocytes. A subset of animals given a dosing holiday was subsequently rechallenged with similar lesions developing but with a more rapid clinical onset. These skin lesions were consistent with type-IV delayed hypersensitivity with some features comparable to bullous drug eruptions in humans. A relationship between these findings and the intended mode of action for these compounds could not be ruled out, given the occurrence across different chemotypes.

Improving the odds of success in drug discovery: choosing the best compounds for in vivo toxicology studies.

A set of molecules that advanced into exploratory animal toxicology studies (two species) was examined to determine what properties contributed to success in these safety studies. Compounds were rigorously evaluated across numerous safety end points and classified as "pass" if a suitable in vivo therapeutic index (TI) was achieved for advancement into regulatory toxicology studies. The most predictive end point contributing to compound survival was a predicted human efficacious concentration (Ceff) of ≤250 nM (total drug) and ≤40 nM (free drug). This trend held across a wide range of CNS modes of action, encompassing targets such as enzymes, G-protein-coupled receptors, ion channels, and transporters.

Mode of action associated with development of hemangiosarcoma in mice given pregabalin and assessment of human relevance.

Pregabalin increased the incidence of hemangiosarcomas in carcinogenicity studies of 2-year mice but was not tumorigenic in rats. Serum bicarbonate increased within 24 h of pregabalin administration in mice and rats. Rats compensated appropriately, but mice developed metabolic alkalosis and increased blood pH. Local tissue hypoxia and increased endothelial cell proliferation were also confirmed in mice alone. The combination of hypoxia and sustained increases in endothelial cell proliferation, angiogenic growth factors, dysregulated erythropoiesis, and macrophage activation is proposed as the key event in the mode of action (MOA) for hemangiosarcoma formation. Hemangiosarcomas occur spontaneously in untreated control mice but occur only rarely in humans. The International Programme on Chemical Safety and International Life Sciences Institute developed a Human Relevance Framework (HRF) analysis whereby presence or absence of key events can be used to assess human relevance. The HRF combines the MOA with an assessment of biologic plausibility in humans to assess human relevance. This manuscript compares the proposed MOA with Hill criteria, a component of the HRF, for strength, consistency, specificity, temporality, and dose response, with an assessment of key biomarkers in humans, species differences in response to disease conditions, and spontaneous incidence of hemangiosarcoma to evaluate human relevance. Lack of key biomarker events in the MOA in rats, monkeys, and humans supports a species-specific process and demonstrates that the tumor findings in mice are not relevant to humans at the clinical dose of pregabalin. Based on this collective dataset, clinical use of pregabalin would not pose an increased risk for hemangiosarcoma to humans.